Informative Masterclass
How to Protect your Family’s Assets and Leave a Lasting Legacy
Save Your Spot Now!

White Plains & New City, New York Estate Planning & Elder Law Firm

Confused by Your Hospital Bill? You’re Not Alone.

April 2, 2019
David Parker, Esq.
David Parker, White Plains and New City NY Estate Planning Attorney
David Parker, Esq.
David Parker is an attorney who specializes in Estate Planning and Elder Law and has been practicing law for 30 years. Be it Wills, Trusts, Powers of Attorney, Health Care Proxies, or Medicaid Planning, David provides comprehensive and caring counsel for seniors and their families. A large portion of David’s practice is asset protection strategies so that families do not lose their hard earned savings to nursing home care costs. He also handles probate administration for the settlement of estates.
Although the legislation was supposed to address the problem of consumer confusion about how much hospitals charge for their services, in application, the inaccurate posted prices probably increase the confusion.

If you have ever read a medical bill from a procedure, test, surgery, or hospitalization, you might not recognize quite a few of the charges. It can be difficult, if not impossible, to piece together the care you received from looking at the statement. This fact can be quite frustrating, particularly when you have to pay a chunk of the bill out of pocket, for deductibles, co-pays and coinsurance. Confused by your hospital bill? You're not alone.

A federal law requires hospitals to post what they charge online, but the numbers they post seldom have any relevance to the amounts that an individual will have to pay. The healthcare facilities seem to view their posted rates as a “list price" or the starting point for negotiations.

Although the legislation was supposed to address the problem of consumer confusion about how much hospitals charge for their services, in application, the inaccurate posted prices probably increase the confusion. Imagine the frustration if you went online to find out how much a hospital will charge for the procedure you need, only to get the bill and find that none of the numbers matches up. Some experts say that patients actually pay more than the posted cost.

Everything Is Open for Negotiation

Because they have the clout to do so, insurance companies start with the posted or list price and negotiate lower numbers with the hospitals. Many hospitals use a sliding scale or other financial aid programs, so the lower income patients can pay discounted rates for their services. Patients who do not have health insurance, can usually negotiate lower prices with the hospital.

Of course, the government does not care what prices the hospitals post for their services. Medicare disregards the posted prices entirely and tells the hospitals how much Medicare will pay them for their services.

Hospital executives often assume that patients only care about the out-of-pocket portion of the hospital bill. The danger of this mentality is that some insurance coverage has a lifetime benefits cap. If you receive a diagnosis of a significant medical condition or you experience a catastrophic injury, you might need every available dollar within that lifetime maximum for your current and future medical expenses. If a hospital padded previous bills, such as charging you for units of blood that you did not receive, many of those precious dollars may have gone to waste.

How to Address the Confusion

We wish we had a solution for how you can make sense of your hospital bill. However, at present, there is no such answer. Some people in the healthcare industry recommend that the patient call the hospital before a procedure or inpatient stay and speak with a financial counselor to get an estimate of their out-of-pocket costs.

Realize, however, that services for surgeons, anesthesiologists, radiologists, and other physicians usually are not part of the hospital's estimate. To prevent wasteful charges reducing your lifetime insurance funds, request a paper bill from the hospital or your insurance company after the procedure and dispute incorrect charges.

Every state has different laws, so talk with an elder law attorney near you about how your state’s laws vary from the general law of this article.


AARP. “Hospital Price Postings Confuse Consumers.” (accessed March 7, 2019)


Share This Post
Stay Informed
Subscribe To Our FREE Estate Planning, Probate and Elder Law Newsletter

Book Your Free Initial Consultation With Parker Law Firm Today
Get Started Now

The 15 minute initial phone call is designed as a simple way for you to get to know us, and for our team to learn more about your unique estate planning needs.

Book an Initial Call
Book A Call With Parker Law Firm
Parker Law Firm
White Plains Location

222 Bloomingdale Rd #301,
White Plains, NY 10605

New City Location

120 North Main Street, Suite 203,
New City, NY 10956

IMS - Estate Planning and Elder Law Practice Growth Advisors
Powered by