Most people assume their spouse or closest family member can step in if something happens. In New York, that is not always the case.
A health care proxy is what gives someone the legal authority to act for you. As an elder law lawyer New York families work with, I often see how this document becomes essential at the exact moment no one expected.
A health care proxy allows you to name someone to make medical decisions if you are unable to communicate.
This situation can arise more often than people think. It may happen during a medical procedure, after an accident, or as part of a longer-term health issue. Without this document, even close family members may not automatically have the authority to act. In some cases, loved ones may need to go through a court process just to make basic medical decisions.
That delay can add stress during an already difficult time.
When there is no health care proxy in place, decisions do not simply default to the “closest” person.
Instead, your family may face court involvement to appoint a guardian, disagreements about what you would have wanted, and delays in care decisions. These situations can become emotionally charged, especially when opinions differ about treatment or end-of-life care.
This is where many people get stuck.
It may feel natural to choose a spouse or oldest child, but the better question is: who can actually carry out your wishes under pressure?
Look for someone who is:
Remember that this decision is for the future. Naming someone close in age may seem logical now, but years later, they may not be able to serve when needed. Geography also plays a role. If your proxy lives far away, being present during a medical emergency can be challenging.
It often makes sense to name a primary proxy along with one or more backups. This helps avoid gaps if your first choice is unavailable.
Naming someone without discussing your wishes puts them in a difficult position. They may be forced to make decisions without knowing what you would want.
A better approach is to talk through:
These conversations do not need to be perfect. They just need to happen before a crisis.
Even thoughtful plans can fall short if a few details are overlooked.
Common problems include choosing someone who avoids conflict, failing to name a backup, not updating the document over time, or assuming family members will “figure it out.” In real-life situations, emotions can run high, and your proxy needs to be able to stand firm when needed.
A health care proxy is one part of a broader plan.
It often works alongside a living will, which explains your treatment preferences, and a durable power of attorney, which allows someone to handle financial matters if you cannot. When these documents are aligned, they can make it easier for your family to act without confusion or delay.
Working with an elder law lawyer in New York can help ensure these pieces work together in a practical way.
Yes. In New York, a spouse does not automatically have full legal authority to make medical decisions for you in every situation. A health care proxy helps avoid uncertainty and gives clear authority.
You can update your health care proxy if your circumstances or preferences change. It’s often a good idea to review your documents periodically, especially after major life events.
It’s generally better to name one primary person and then backups. Naming multiple people to act at the same time can sometimes create confusion or slow down decision-making.
This is not just a legal form; it’s a decision that can affect how your care is handled and how your family experiences a difficult moment.
Attorney David Parker works with individuals and families throughout New York to put practical plans in place that reflect their values and priorities. If you haven’t reviewed your health care proxy recently, or if you’re unsure who to name, it may be worth taking a closer look now. Book a call today.
References: Kiplinger (Aug. 7, 2025) “I’m an Estate Planning Attorney: These Are the Two Legal Documents Everyone Should Have” and Forbes (April 10, 2019) “How to Select A Healthcare Proxy”
The 15 minute initial phone call is designed as a simple way for you to get to know us, and for our team to learn more about your unique estate planning needs.
